(Pocket-lint) - Amazon's line of Echo Dot speaker was one of the more settled and consistent in tech over the last few years - its puck-shaped design was clearly doing something right as the Alexa speaker sold in its multitudes. 

However, few things in tech last forever and Amazon's taken the wraps off an entirely new look for the Echo Dot, very much a shrunken-down version of the new mainline Echo. It's a pretty radical departure, and with the 3rd Generation Echo Dot still very much on sale, you might be wondering which of the two you should pick up. We've compared them in detail across a few categories, below. 

squirrel_widget_2683192

Design

  • 4th gen: 100 x 100 x 89 mm
  • 3rd gen: 43 x 99 x 99 mm

There's no getting around it - Amazon's changed the Echo Dot's design pretty radically when it comes to looks, going from that distinctive puck shape to a globe of a smart speaker in the new version. 

That has also had a slightly inescapable impact on the Dot's size - it's got a lot taller, effectively. The actual footprint of the speaker is very similar to the previouversion, but with a lot more height. 

While that's given Amazon a bunch of space to fit in more tech, as we'll show later, it does mean that the new Echo Dot won't necessarily fit in as many nooks and crannies as its predecessor. The new version is also a little heavier, too, as a result of its increased size but also because of the aluminium used in its construction, compared to the more plastic feel of the older speaker. 

The new design also cannot be wall-mounted, which is actually key - it's why Amazon's not discontinuing the older puck speakers, which can easily be hung on a wall if that's the most convenient spot for them. 

Otherwise, both speakers share the Alexa light-strip to let you know when the voice assistant is listening, or turned off, as well as four buttons on the top to let you adjust the volume, mute the speaker or confirm a range actions. 

You can get both generations in black, grey and light blue colours, but a pink option is reserved for the older speaker at present. Both generations are also available with an embedded clock display for at-a-glance timing information, for a small bump in the price. 

squirrel_widget_2683193

squirrel_widget_167722

Finally, the new Echo Dot also has two variant designs aimed at children, which are perfect if you're looking for a smart speaker to put in a little one's bedroom or playroom. 

squirrel_widget_2683194

Sound quality

  • Both generations: 1.6” speaker

Interestingly, Amazon doesn't seem to have made a particular reinvention of the sound design behind the fabric shroud of the new Echo Dot - it's still got that 1.6” speaker to provide the volume. 

Now, going by the performance of the older Echo Dot, that's no issue - for a small speaker, the Dot line has been producing really impressive sound quality for some time, so no change isn't bad news. That said, given the increased size of the newer Dot, you could be forgiven for hoping for an improvement. 

They might sound slightly different in the using, which we'll be able to establish with some testing when we go hands on, but for now it's a safe assumption that there's no enormous difference. That still means, though, that you'll get a real upgrade compared to listening to music from your phone, even if either Echo Dot model can't compete with bigger speakers. 

On both models there is also a 3.5mm port in case you want to pipe audio in via cable. 

Alexa and smart home connectivity

When it comes to Alexa, you'll get pretty similar experiences on both generations of Echo Dot speakers - as a lot of the assistant's processing is done in the cloud regardless.

However, the new AZ1 Neural Edge chip that's in the newer Echo Dot does mean that Alexa should be slightly faster and more responsive on the newer speaker, as you might expect.

Their smart home integration potential, meanwhile, is identical - anything you can do on an older Echo Dot will still work on the new spherical model, and the reverse should be true, too. 

Price and conclusions

As Amazon often does with its product refreshes, the new Echo Dot has debuted at the same price as the old one, so there's no change there. However, the older puck-shaped model has now had an instant discount of 20% applied, and we wouldn't be suprised if it gets either a permanently lower price point, or is simply discounted regularly enough to not need one.

That means that while they have the same RRP, you should be able to get the older Echo Dot at a slightly lower price than the new globe. However, the margin won't be big - and we think it's really the design that should sway most people. 

If you're a fan of the new spherical look, then the newer speaker is going to be right up your street, but if you look at it and can't get on board, the older Echo Dot might be more palatable. Ultimately, as with so many things, it comes down to taste!

squirrel_widget_2683192

squirrel_widget_145811

Writing by Max Freeman-Mills.