Google Chrome OS - First Look review

What does Google's new OS offer?

Google Chrome OS - First Look
Reviewer
Duncan Geere
Review Date
21 November 2009
Manufacturer
Google
Price as reviewed
£free
Latest price
compare

First Look

Google has dropped the source code of Chrome OS into the wild, so we thought we'd take a look and see if it lives up to the lofty hype that's been placed upon it. Depending on who you believe, Chrome OS could either sink without trace or obliterate Microsoft, Apple and Linux wholesale.

The truth, as always, is neither. Well, not just yet anyway. Chrome is still at a very early stage. It runs, but there's not a whole lot you can do when it's running - other than log in, browse the web, check your battery status, and turn network adaptors on and off.

When you first boot up the OS you'll be faced with a login screen. Put your Google address and password in and it'll confirm them and let you enter the operating system. You'll then be faced with a browser window showing your GMail, and Google Calendar. These work exactly how they do in any other OS's browser window.

Up in the top right, there is a couple of icons that let you access the browser menus, see your network connectivity status (turning on and off wireless or Ethernet, for example) and monitor your battery. These seem to work mostly as advertised, but a few of the menu items - like "options" - are duplicated in the browser.

There's a Start Menu-esque icon in the top left that takes you to a page inviting you to sign into Google Short Links. This didn't recognise our username and password, so we couldn't get any further on this page. It doesn't appear to be treated as a regular browser window, though - we couldn't close or unpin it like we could with the mail and calendar tabs.

Hitting the new tab button, or using the Ctrl-T shortcut, brings you to Chrome's default new tab page complete with "quick-dial" shortcuts to your most-viewed web pages. There's links to themes from a wide range of artists that can skin the OS, though the Google ones are almost universally more attractive than the artist-created ones.

There's also a link to the extensions gallery, though this isn't working at the time of writing - just giving a "Coming soon..." message. By the time the Chrome OS makes it into a full release, there'll likely be a host of extensions to choose from that'll offer a bunch of additional functionality that isn't built in to the platform by default.

We did find a few bugs. Going into the bookmarks manager got us stuck until we created a new bookmark and double-clicked it. That took us back to the browser window. Also, unpinning the mail and calendar tabs with a right-click and closing them took us to a blank desktop that we couldn't access anything from. Only a reboot of our virtual machine fixed that. 

 

First Impressions

For the moment, Chrome OS is pretty much just a browser in a Linux shell. That isn't going to set the world on fire, free or not. It's fast - it boots in just 7 seconds - but it's not exactly functional. Overall performance was difficult to judge, due to running it in a virtual machine, but it didn't seem too painful.

Chrome OS has potential because Google may well be making a play into netbooks and smartbooks in the same way that it has with Android and smartphones. If that's the case, then the fruits of the project could be some way away - Android is only just starting to make waves, more than a year after its release.

Chrome OS is one to watch, but we wouldn't recommend you switch to it as your primary operating system just yet.

 

 

Related
Full tags
Software, Operating Systems, Google, Chrome OS
UK Shopping
Amazon.co.uk, play.com, pixmania.co.uk, Currys.co.uk, Dixons.co.uk, 7dayshop.com, ebay.co.uk
US Shopping
Amazon.com, bestbuy.com, ebay.com

share Subscribe to RSS feeds email story save story print story pdf

Comments

  • Perhaps ChromeOS should have some kind of app store for web apps. This would serve to:

    1. simplify the process of discovering web apps: there are millions (billions?) of web sites on the internet.

    2. describe web apps: app category (game, office app, ...), brief description, online/offline support, cost, user reviews & rankings.

    3. handle financial transactions: centralize the handling of purchases, subscriptions, etc. versus dealing with each individual web app provider (many providers may prefer the handling of this to be "outsourced" anyway).

    4. provide a uniform login/authentication mechanism: who wants to manage 100s of user ids & passwords?

    5. handle the activation/deactivation of web apps: if a user fails to pay or unsubscribes to an app/service, their access should be disabled.
    Posted by HereAndNow, USA
  • Just want to say bravo on all the Chrome OS coverage. But also surely it's just bare because it's very early days? I'd be very very surprised if it wasn't not only functional but also a breeze to use and become accustommed to by the time of its release. It'd be silly for Google not to make that effort anyway Posted by Whitster, United Kingdom
  • I'm not sold on this, but then I only use the Google search engine and Google Earth products in my day to day.

    If my reliance on Google services was more prolific I might feel that this was worthwhile, as it is, it just seems like change for the sake of change, with no added value and the annoyance of having to learn Google specific tools over the various third party tools I'm already using.
    Posted by L.Rawlins, UK
  • I got the more useful information from the
    http://www.techarena.in/review/18377-google-chrome-os-chromium-os.htm
    Posted by yureka, India

(Will not be published)

  (Next time sign in to bypass captcha)

Compare prices

» Check prices

Top 10 Broadband

Compare 50+
broadband packages

Home Broadband »

Pocket-lint poll

Q. Do you use the same password for everything?

Vote YES Vote NO

» LAST TIME
When asked Do you check emails, twitter or surf the internet in the loo? 65% said yes and 35% said no

About Pocket-lint

Pocket-lint is your one stop shop for gadgets, technology and consumer electronics, bringing you the low-down on the latest televisions, cameras, phones, GPS and much more. Whether it's learning about what's hot in the world of Apple, finding out about the latest home cinema kit from Samsung and Sony or merely seeing what not to buy, we have you covered. So check out our reviews, news, comment, hands-on photo galleries and videos. Enjoy.

Top products

tip us on news

reviews hub

Rss feed

Follow us on Twitter