Down in the Valley - DVD review

Can Norton save this modern day Brokeback Mountain?

Down in the Valley - DVD. Home Cinema, DVD, Drama, David Morse 0
Reviewer
Dan Hall
Review Date
15 March 2007
Price as reviewed
£20
Latest price
compare

Our score

6/10 6/10 See more with this score

Full Review

Following the recent trend for modern-day westerns (think "Brokeback Mountain" and "Three Burials") Ed Norton’s latest is a cowboy drama set in the suburban sprawl of today’s San Fernando Valley.

When high school student Tobe (Wood) meets a charming drifter named Harlan Fairfax Carruthers (Norton complete with ill-advised handlebar tash) she is instantly attracted to his old-fashioned manners and refreshing outlook on life.

As their relationship progresses however, Tobe’s father (Morse), a no non-sense prison warder, begins to see through Harlan’s act and orders him to stop seeing his daughter. This unwelcome news then triggers an ugly mental disintegration in Harlan that leads to an inevitably bloody finale.

Meandering aimlessly, much like Harlan, the script is full of poetic musings like "I just want to step out of my heart, sit under the stars and talk with my true voice" or "the sea is about as close to forever as I can imagine" that begin to grate despite some first class acting from the uniformally excellent cast.

Norton is particulalry impressive - in a turn not dissimilar to his "Fight Club" role – as the seemingly mild-mannered dreamer with a dangerous streak lurking beneath the surface.

This beautifully shot film also raises some interesting questions about what effects movie myths can have on impressionable minds, but the contrived ending and the script’s unwelcome tendency to drift mean "DITV" is definitely not essential viewing.

Verdict

Reminiscent of 70s independents such as "Badlands" and "Taxi Driver" this nihilistic modern-day cowboy story will certainly not be to everyone’s taste.

Rating: 15
Staring: Edward Norton Evan Rachel Wood David Morse" Bruce Dern, Rory Culkin
Directed by: David Jacobson
Extras: None

Full tags
Home Cinema, DVD, Drama, David Morse
UK Shopping
Amazon.co.uk, play.com, pixmania.co.uk, Currys.co.uk, Dixons.co.uk, 7dayshop.com, ebay.co.uk
US Shopping
Amazon.com, bestbuy.com, ebay.com

share Subscribe to RSS feeds email story save story print story pdf

Comments

(Will not be published)

  (Next time sign in to bypass captcha)

About Pocket-lint

Pocket-lint is your one stop shop for gadgets, technology and consumer electronics, bringing you the low-down on the latest televisions, cameras, phones, GPS and much more. Whether it's learning about what's hot in the world of Apple, finding out about the latest home cinema kit from Samsung and Sony or merely seeing what not to buy, we have you covered. So check out our reviews, news, comment, hands-on photo galleries and videos. Enjoy.

Pocket-lint.com poll

Q. Do you still buy CDs?

Vote YES Vote NO

» LAST TIME
When asked Do you want the Droid by Motorola? 53% said yes and 47% said no

Top 10 Broadband

Compare 50+
broadband packages

Home Broadband »

Top products

tip us on news

reviews hub

Rss feed

Follow us on Twitter