27 June 2011 10:45 GMT / By Rik Henderson
Although Apple is mega rich and has rapidly become the most valuable technology company in the world, thanks mainly to the iPhone and iPad, it is also in danger of extinction because of the way it functions.
As a closed system - you must buy your applications from Apple, the operating system is locked down by Apple, and there is no room for customisation above and beyond what Apple allows - it is historically doomed to fail.
Speaking at the inaugural Forward with Ford Futuring and Trends Conference in Dearborn, Michigan, US, tech expert and Gear and Technology editor at NBC's Today Show, Paul Hochman, explained that closed systems in nature and beyond ultimately die out: "Apple’s in big trouble. They’re sitting on piles of cash, but they are sitting on a closed system. In biology, in history, a closed system never survives," he said.
And it's not the only company at risk. Applying the same logic to motor cars, or specifically the entertainment system inside, Hochman bemoaned Ford's rivals' decisions to lock down tech in a vehicle that might be owned for five years or more: "General Motors has a closed system. Essentially, it bolts a phone into the car." With no chance of upgrading the hardware itself, even though entertainment and communication technology moves on quickly.
It is for this reason that he applauds Ford for adopting an open system with its MyFord Touch and SYNC Applink technologies. Both of them are fully (and regularly) upgradable in software terms, and rely on an external handset (iPhone, Android, etc) for communication and, even, app support.
As an open system, it allows you to swap in and swap out elements as you see fit, and even run applications from your external device on the in-car screen. Plus, if you upgrade your handset to a 4G phone, for example, you can use its faster connectivity. The GM version is locked to the specification originally sold.
Essentially, the capabilities of your Ford in-car system, therefore, can be supercharged by the addition of a third-party device.
Could you imagine Apple allowing that?
What do you think? Is Apple's closed system doomed in the long run? Let us know in the comments below...
Read our review of the new iPad (3rd generation)
Apple, Forward with Ford, iPhone, iPad, iOS 5, Ford



Nokia: Youths are fed up with iPhone, baffled by Android EXCLUSIVE: We offer something different
Apple iPad (3rd generation) Is it really resolutionary?
Best new iPad apps to show off the Retina Display UPDATED: How to best test your hardware
Which smartphone has the best camera? Top mobiles put through their paces
Samsung and Apple looking at new waterproof smartphone tech CES 2012: Nano-technology
Leica X2 pictures and hands-on Premium compact, premium price
HTC Desire C pictures and hands-on Could sell like er, wildfire
BlackBerry Curve 9320 A BB for beginners?
APP OF THE DAY: Tom Daley Dive 2012 review (iPad / iPhone / iPod touch) Splooosh!
Sony Vaio E Series pictures and hands-on Everyday laptops
Motorola RAZR MAXX pictures and hands-on "Longest talktime of any smartphone"
Three unveils details of cheaper MiFi device for Wi-Fi on the go Cheaper, we just don't know by how much
Leica M9 Monochrom pictures and hands-on Will you beat your wallet black and blue?
Panasonic Viera TX-L55WT50B Top of the range LED-backlit LCD TV
Lego creates exclusive Team GB Olympic minifigs Going for gold
Diablo III collector's edition pictures and hands-on
Canon EOS 650D coming in June - specs leaked About time and all
Leica M9 Hermes pictures and hands-on A snip at £18,000
Sony Vaio T13 Ultrabook pictures and hands-on Sony's first Ultra
Android fragmentation report suggests app developers should test on Samsung phones first 681,900 devices studied
Olympus OM-D E-M5 review
The compact system camera to beat all others?
HTC One S review
The new sensation
Nokia Lumia 900 review
Is big beautiful?
Panasonic Lumix DMC-TZ30 review
20x zoom compact impresses
HTC One V review
V for victory?
FIFA 12: UEFA Euro 2012 review
Lacks polish, if not the Polish
Huawei Ascend G300 review
Big bang for your hundred quid
Asus Transformer Pad TF300T review
Transforms your money in to a great tablet
BlackBerry Mini Keyboard for PlayBook review
Will this make working on the go easier?
Fujifilm X-Pro1 review
Like a Leica
Nikon Coolpix P510 review
Does the P510 zoom beyond expectations?
Volkswagen Beetle Design 1.2TSi DSG review
The bug is back. Again.
Olympus SZ-14 review
Small price, big zoom
The Walking Dead: The Game review
Fleshed out zombie bonanza