2 June 2011 20:01 GMT / By Paul Lamkin
Nokia CEO Stephen Elop took to the Qualcomm Uplinq stage in San Diego on Thursday to deliver a keynote address where, as is becoming common for the under pressure boss, he pulled no punches.
The straight talking former Microsoft man described exactly why Nokia chose to tread the Windows Phone 7 path rather than the green-brick road of Android, and also described how Nokia is no longer in straight competition with other manufacturers in a device environment, but rather fighting on the side of Microsoft in a mobile OS arena.
"We believe that what has happened over the last couple of years is that there has been a shift from the battle of devices to a war of ecosystems," he said.
"Our strategic premise at Nokia is that there is an opportunity for a third and competitive ecosystem to emerge and that is the basis on which we are going forward."
Elop described how he felt that Apple changed the game when it launched the iPhone although he described the Cupertino company's approach as "closed" - where developers could only "participate within certain boundaries within a box".
He went on to say that it was Apple, therefore, that eventually created Android - as Google filled the vacuum for developers wanting to work in a more open environment. Elop's slideshow displayed the Apple logo on a closed box and the Android one on an open one - but one with flaps at the top.
"The flaps are still there," he said. "And it remains to be seen how open, and for how long."
When describing the specific reasons that Nokia decided against a Google partnership Elop said: "With Google we did believe that we would be joining an ecosystem which is on a winning trajectory.
"But our big concern would be that we would not be able to differentiate enough. There are already so many companies already piling into that space, all doing innovative and interesting things, that it would be hard to stand out amongst them."
It's clear that Elop sees Windows Phone 7 (or 7.5 rather) as Nokia's baby now - even describing how it is just a secondary device for manufacturers like Samsung and HTC and stating how what Nokia is bringing to the table in terms of mapping, navigation and the like could "define the third ecosystem".
Nokia has been criticised heavily form some quarters for not choosing to team up with Google and make Android devices but it's obvious that the company, or more specifically Elop himself, genuinely believes that it can make Windows Phone its own, and re-establish its position as a smartphone powerhouse.
Whether it succeeds or not remains to be seen, but one thing's for sure - it won't be due to a lack of effort from the CEO.
Is Nokia on the way out, or has Elop pulled the strings to save it just in time? And was Windows Phone the right option? Let us know what you think using the comments below.
Stephen Elop, Phones, Mobile phones, Nokia, Android, Microsoft, Windows Phone 7



Sony Xperia S pictures and hands-on CES 2012: See-through
Sony Xperia S Is Sony's best yet good enough?
HTC One X X marks the spot
HTC Explorer A phone for people who make calls
Nokia: Youths are fed up with iPhone, baffled by Android EXCLUSIVE: We offer something different
Is Facebook about to buy Opera to create own Facebook browser? EXCLUSIVE: Pocket-lint source tells us "yes"
APP OF THE DAY: The Weather Channel review (iPhone / iPod touch) Tonight for the first time, just about half-past ten...
Mazda CX5 2.2 TDI AWD A very zoomy SUV
Which smartphone is best for the sun? Screens for the Summer
Jony Ive: Next Apple product is our most important and best work yet Better than iPod, iPad and iPhone?
Batman Nokia Lumia 900: Limited edition phone heading to UK Who are you? I'm Batman
Dragon's Dogma Adventure time
Tom Clancy’s Ghost Recon: Future Soldier Roger likes a Tango at 12 o'clock
Porsche 911 Carrera (991) 2012 pictures and hands-on WANT
Canon EOS 5D MK III It's a hat-trick
Robert Moog Google doodle best yet, even better than Les Paul Synthesizer synthesiser
British Gas turns Team GB swimming stars into superheroes Aquanauts assemble
APP OF THE DAY: Mini Motor review (Android, iPhone and iPad) Top-down. Top app.
Microsoft Office coming to iPad and Android tablets this November A change of heart?
Pint of Guinness reveals scannable QR code Novelty drinking
Olympus OM-D E-M5 review
The compact system camera to beat all others?
Nokia Lumia 900 review
Is big beautiful?
HTC One V review
V for victory?
Huawei Ascend G300 review
Big bang for your hundred quid
FIFA 12: UEFA Euro 2012 review
Lacks polish, if not the Polish
Asus Transformer Pad TF300T review
Transforms your money in to a great tablet
Nikon Coolpix P510 review
Does the P510 zoom beyond expectations?
Fujifilm X-Pro1 review
Like a Leica
Volkswagen Beetle Design 1.2TSi DSG review
The bug is back. Again.
BlackBerry Curve 9320 review
A BB for beginners?
Fujifilm FinePix HS30EXR review
Can Fujifilm’s latest put the ‘super’ in superzoom?
HP Envy 14 Spectre review
The Ultrabook that isn't an Ultrabook
The Walking Dead: The Game review
Fleshed out zombie bonanza
Nikon Coolpix S6300 review
Point, shoot and scoot