Palm Pre vs Palm Pixi

Just what has the Pre lost to make it lite?

Palm Pre vs Palm Pixi

10 September 2009 19:42 GMT / By Dan Sung

There's a trend appearing in the mobile world of the super-smartphone and the junior sidekick. While the world had Apple fever over the updates to the iPod range and whether or not the Fab Four would appear - well, at least one or two of them - Palm announced a lite version of the Pre dubbed the Palm Pixi.

We've all read the words of the nips and tucks here and there but there's nothing like a good old side by side comparison to really hit home the differences, so here it is:

Palm vs pixie

What's obvious straight away is that Palm hasn't taken too much. It's largely about power and performance rather than functionality. A lower spec chipset and complement of RAM will mean that running simultaneous apps won't be quite as smooth on the Pixi but it'll still be possible. Similarly there's still a camera with AF and LED flash but a significant drop on ultimate image size down to two megapixels. That said, so long as it's the same same glassware and chips, is that really a problem?

The screen is probably the most major loss of all, shrinking down in size as well as colour vibrancy but it still functions in the same way. It's just a question of whether you can look at the detail clearly enough. The issue behind the issue though, is will this cause a problem for app developers who now have to program for two different screen sizes? Perhaps not the biggest help for the future of the Palm Beta App Catalogue.

The lack of Wi-Fi in the Pixi might not be quite the problem it appears to be, so long as you have an unlimited data package to go with the 3G access and otherwise, the phones are largely the same.

There are two area though where the smaller handset has an edge. With the Pixi being a candy bar phone, it means that the QWERTY keys are higher raised than those on the Pre that must slide under the casing. Reports are that although the Pixi's keys are smaller, higher nobbling makes its QWERTY easier to use. Food for thought for the chunky thumbed.

The other bonus, which isn't likely to last, is that the Pixi comes with integration of Facebook and Twitter messages into conversation threads that the Pre doesn't currently support. There's been no official word but it seems highly likely that the next software update will bring that to the Pre too.

The bottom line on the Pixi is that, like it's name, it's to appeal a more fashion conscious, money light sector who'd rather have the social networking functionality, something smaller in their jeans and less of a heavy pocket computer. The final proof of the fact is the limited edition release of the phone which will see artists illustrate the rubberised scratch-proof back covers.

The Pre's not exactly a fortune at $150 in the States - we're still foot tapping over in the UK - but expect the Pixi to be considerably less. That may not make much of a difference in America but on this isle the little cousin could be a serious tempter against a high priced Pre on O2. Is this another reason why we've been waiting?

As far as Palm goes though, on paper, you've got to hand it to them that they seem to have done a very neat job of walking the trade off tight rope with the Pixi.

Related
Full tags
Phones, Mobile phones, O2, Palm, Palm Pixi, Palm Pre, Features
UK Shopping
mobiles.co.uk, three.co.uk, carphonewarehouse.co.uk, Nokia.co.uk, o2.co.uk, orange.co.uk, phones4u.co.uk, t-mobile.co.uk, vodafone.co.uk, ebay.co.uk
US Shopping
bestbuy.com, ebay.com

share Subscribe to RSS feeds email story save story print story pdf

Comments

  • It's a button, not a trackball. Posted by asmathews, USA
  • Sure hope they do a better job with the pixis storage I have already ran out of app storage room and have to delete to install new. Go figure what good is it to have good app store when you are so limited to the number of apps you can install. Posted by Jess Newcomb, United States
  • jess stfu and go buy a mIdolPhone to go with your cramps Posted by john, US
  • whooooooooooooooooooooooooooo palm pre i number one
    Posted by bob, usa
  • In the article it says that both of the cameras have AF (auto-focus?) The cameras for these devices do NOT have auto focus... Posted by Cnote1287, USA
  • I'm a power user currently using a 755p. Have list of things about the Pre I don't like so have been waiting (ex. need full DocsToGo, want memos with categories, and address with categories, etc.). Most of all, I use my phone one handed A LOT, and don't want to constantly be flicking around on the large screen or the painful process of zooming in on google maps with one hand (I'd likely drop the phone!). Wish there was a D-Pad for easier one handed navigation (clean look is nice, and copying the iPhone design is one thing, but Palm has always been better a keeping ease of use top of mind; i see the one button approach as a serious miss), and hate that there's no menu button. Anyway, I like the Pixi form factor (lower power aside). The screen will still be larger and a quality upgrade from the Treo, and I believe that I'll be able to do one handed navigation more easily due to its smaller size...need to test this. Looking forward to its release! Now can I get it on prepaid?! Posted by PrepaidWirelessGuy, USA
  • Poop Posted by Poop, poop
  • i dont see a point to the pixi besides it being smaller and not being a slide. it has a less powerful cpu and ram... dumb. Posted by Ryan, United States
  • the pixi is just as good as the pre, the pixi may have a smaller camera, but its a buisness phone and a camera isnt that important. even if you don't have wifi with the pixi, there is still an internet connection. and the pixi is easier to use. i think the sliding feature with the pre is inconvienient. its hard to slide and it curves. it's a pain. Posted by samantha, dfsaldsk
  • The Pre is integrated with Facebook and twitter via the latest update Posted by Ross, USA
  • PALM PIXI RULES!!!! Posted by nicole, florida!!
  • AF doesnt stand for auto-focus but for auto-flash Posted by your mom, usa
  • With prices dropping daily, the Pre is a no brainer at $79. My prediction is, we'll see it drop to $49 from January 2010. It's by far the best smartphone/PDA on the market today! http://tiny.cc/NljQu Posted by Audrey Peters, U.S.
  • UGH, why cant they put in an auto focus on the pre? im just sayin, is it REALLY THAT hard? D: Posted by Ur uncle, Bob
  • i honestly dont see the f****** difference between the two. i just wish they would give more detail and say which one is better already. Posted by doggie, united States
  • i love my palm pre! its da best phone ive ever had! i dont like da pixi its too small not just in size but da screen! Posted by angela, usa

(Will not be published)

  (Next time sign in to bypass captcha)

Latest in Phones

Latest on Pocket-lint

Top 10 Broadband

Compare 50+
broadband packages

Home Broadband »

Pocket-lint poll

Q. Do you use the same password for everything?

Vote YES Vote NO

» LAST TIME
When asked Do you check emails, twitter or surf the internet in the loo? 65% said yes and 35% said no

About Pocket-lint

Pocket-lint is your one stop shop for gadgets, technology and consumer electronics, bringing you the low-down on the latest televisions, cameras, phones, GPS and much more. Whether it's learning about what's hot in the world of Apple, finding out about the latest home cinema kit from Samsung and Sony or merely seeing what not to buy, we have you covered. So check out our reviews, news, comment, hands-on photo galleries and videos. Enjoy.

Top products

tip us on news

reviews hub

Rss feed

Follow us on Twitter