Are Macs for left-handed people?

COMMENT: It's all in the mind - and the desktop

Are Macs for left-handed people?. Software, Comment, Apple, Windows, Steve Jobs, Bill Gates, Mac software 1 View more images

21 August 2009 18:06 GMT / By Dan Sung

PCs and Macs are very different machines. There are probably more obvious statements than that in the world but not many. From the design of the computers, to their strengths and weaknesses, the sweeping contrasts between the two are enormous but sometimes it's the smallest variations that are the most telling of the them all.

For example, have you ever taken a good look at something as simple their desktops? There's the recent addition of the Dock and obvious graphic subtleties but one thing, although noticeable, that barely seems to register is the icons and where they sit on the screen. Sure you can drag and drop them wherever you like but the default auto-arrange on the Mac is to the right side of the screen and, with Windows, it's to the left.

No big shakes, you say? O ye of little faith. Icons on the right-hand side of your visual field fall into the left-hand side of your brain; meaning that on a Mac, your left hemisphere is occupied while the blank space on the other side of your desktop leaves your right brain to think. With it so far? Good. Now, it might interest you know that the right side of the brain is associated with imagery, graphical and geometric shape analysis, is more intuitive and supports more holistic approach to thinking. Sound familiar to the Apple approach?

Contrast that with a Windows-based machine. With the icons and the mess on the left side, the left brain is free to work and the left brain is sequential, logical, verbal, mathematical and supports a more linear approach to solutions. You could argue that it's represented in the users of these systems and they ways they work - Apple providing holistic machines with everything you need running out of the box and in tune; a more design-orientated, image-friendly appearance and a strength in graphics applications - whereas PCs provide a more hands-on, straight numerical and logical linear-based approach.

It might seem farcical but a recent poll on MacRumours found that 30% of their Mac-using readers were left-handed, and left-handers are right brain dominant. That's three times more than the worldwide split of 90% righties to 10% southpaws. And it doesn't stop there. The most recent figures for the computing market showed that 88.7% of the world uses Windows and 9.63% run with Apple. That's more than pretty close.

So, why then is Bill Gates left-handed and does Steve Jobs favour his right? Why have they been catering for the other end of the market? Well, perhaps it's simply business. There's many more right-handed people than lefties. It's a bigger market, but then, it could be that Steve Jobs took the right side first. However, Gates's fortune could be because left-handed people have a higher propensity for success. A study by Chris McManus of UCL showed that left-handed men who attended college were on average 15% richer than their right-handed counterparts and that figure went up to 26% if they managed to graduate. He also predicted a rise in the proportion of left-handers into the future, so perhaps Jobs has just been playing the long game - on an evolutionary scale.

Maybe Macs are really for left-handed people, maybe Windows are for the rights; maybe Gates is taunting right-handed people who persecuted him with an unstable and frustrating OS and Jobs has been exploiting arty-farty southpaws. Who knows, but the one question really remaining is, does that mean that at around 1% of the market share, Linux is for the ambidextrous?

Related
Full tags
Software, Comment, Apple, Windows, Steve Jobs, Bill Gates, Mac software
UK Shopping
Amazon.co.uk, play.com, pixmania.co.uk, Currys.co.uk, Dixons.co.uk, 7dayshop.com, ebay.co.uk
US Shopping
Amazon.com, bestbuy.com, ebay.com

share Subscribe to RSS feeds email story save story print story pdf

Comments

  • "The most recent figures for the computing market showed that 88.7% of the world uses Windows and 9.63% run with Apple. That's more than pretty close."

    Those figures are incorrect. Net applications has updated their numbers showing Windows is 93.04%, Apple is 4.86%,and Linux is 1.05% of worldwide market share:

    http://marketshare.hitslink.com/operating-system-market-share.aspx?qprid=8
    Posted by warp99, USA
  • I'm left-handed, and a bit dyslexic, too...
    I discovered Macs in 1984, and have never looked back...

    Because Macs used icons, I did not have to scroll thru long lists of items, reading each one, to find the one I wanted. It was a simple advantage back then, but it was so powerful. Every time I try to use a PC (yes, I can if I have to) I thank my lucky stars that the Mac exists.

    I've always been amazed at the kinds of folks who use Macs-
    artists, writers, creative individual thinkers, etc. many more of them left-handed than the general population.

    Posted by RSD, US
  • Windows icons are on the left because when MS copied the Mac, they wanted deniability. See? See? We didn't steal this because our icons are on the left! Get it? On the left!

    Yes, that simple, and that complex.
    Posted by Richard, USA
  • Or maybe the Mac screen arrangement derives from the fact that Western languages, like English, read from left to right, so you reserve the left side of the screen for documents (the focus of interest) and put the marginalia (the icons) on the right. Posted by MichaelC, United States
  • I'm not-quite-ambidextrous (writing is a challenge) and I use Macs, Linux, Windows, and Solaris. Does this tell you anything? :) Posted by Dave52, USA
  • @Dave52-
    Uh... yep, it tells me you're neither left nor right brained...
    you're kinda' somewhere in the middle, now run along and go get a life outside computing :) you're spending way too much time in front of a screen.
    Posted by RSD, us
  • I'm a lefty but a pleasure myself with my right so that it feels like someone else. Posted by Hank Tank, United States
  • What goes to the left-side-of-the-brain is input from the right-eye - not the right hand side of the field, AFAIK. The opposite for the right-side-of-the-brain receiving input from the left eye. The visual field is a synthesis of the right-and-left eyes in "software-the brain", and "firmware-Default Network". See the recent Science News, for the article on "Idle Brain" (Science News, July 18, 2009, Vol 176 #2 - You Are Who You Are By Default).
    Right-and-Left Brain definitions have become trivialized by left-brain simplification. The "linearity" of Windows and the "spatiality" of OS X is not a trivial explanation, but far from the "gestalt" of computer use and how OSes are designed.
    Posted by Vladimir Vooss, United States
  • As a lefty, I've always felt that having scroll bars on the right side of a window is backwards. Since I mouse with my left hand, it always feels as if I'm "reaching over" the window to get to the scroll bar. Posted by TGB, USA
  • Mac icons are on the right because that it is they way that Steve J. and Steve W. first saw them on a Xerox:

    http://images.appleinsider.com/leopard-preview-desktop-3.jpg

    Bill may have wanted to be different for plausible deniability but the plain fact is video drivers are different. When I first stated using windows, having been a mac user, I put my icons on the right. My monitor died and I to use an older lower resolution monitor. Oops I lost my icons. That would not have happened on a mac because it drew the screen starting with the top right corner.

    I strongly believe it is a matter of mainstream v. proprietary drivers.
    Posted by Mark, US
  • Let me just add: The location of the power button behind iMacs, yes, itīs on the left side!!! Posted by Santiago Quiss, Argentina

(Will not be published)

  (Next time sign in to bypass captcha)

Latest in Software

Latest on Pocket-lint.com

About Pocket-lint

Pocket-lint is your one stop shop for gadgets, technology and consumer electronics, bringing you the low-down on the latest televisions, cameras, phones, GPS and much more. Whether it's learning about what's hot in the world of Apple, finding out about the latest home cinema kit from Samsung and Sony or merely seeing what not to buy, we have you covered. So check out our reviews, news, comment, hands-on photo galleries and videos. Enjoy.

Pocket-lint.com poll

Q. Do you still buy CDs?

Vote YES Vote NO

» LAST TIME
When asked Do you want the Droid by Motorola? 53% said yes and 47% said no

Top 10 Broadband

Compare 50+
broadband packages

Home Broadband »

Top products

tip us on news

Rss feed

Follow us on Twitter