Student sues Amazon over Kindle deletion

Class action suit for those affected by Orwell fiasco

Student sues Amazon over Kindle deletion

31 July 2009 10:00 GMT / By Amy-Mae Elliott

A 17-year-old high school student in the States is suing Amazon over its recent ill-advised remote deletion of two George Orwell titles from consumer's Kindles.

Amazon sold consumers the books - 1984 and Animal Farm - but later pulled them when it realised there were copyright issues with those particular versions. The move caused an outcry in the US, and led to a public apology from Amazon CEO Jeff Bezos, who described the hasty move as "stupid".

However, for Justin D. Gawronski, the result was more than a question of improper access, as the student had bought an e-copy of 1984 for a summer assignment and had made electronic notes against the ebook, all of which were lost when Amazon deleted the title.

The class action lawsuit could see others join up to seek "injunctive relief" stopping Amazon from such action in the future, as well as asking for "monetary relief" for those who lost work as a result of Amazon's actions.

Read

Related
Full tags
Biz, Amazon, Kindle, Lawsuits
UK Shopping
Amazon.co.uk, play.com, pixmania.co.uk, Currys.co.uk, Dixons.co.uk, 7dayshop.com, ebay.co.uk
US Shopping
Amazon.com, bestbuy.com, ebay.com

share Subscribe to RSS feeds email story save story print story pdf

Comments

  • beats "the dog ate my homework" and there was never any proof I did it either. Posted by adrianaitken, United Kingdom
  • Hi,
    Just to add that the lawsuit acknowledges that the student found tha this notes were still on the Kindle in a text-file made for users to edit and print from their computers.

    His complaint is that the notes are now 'rendered useless' since Amazon removed the text, as references in his notes include just referring to "this paragraph" and listing the e-reader location number.

    - Andrys
    kindleworld.blogspot.com.
    Posted by Andrys Basten, USA
  • We took this case into the people's court at allrise.com. join in to influence the verdict in this case http://www.allrise.com/cases/Justin_D._Gawronski-vs-Amazon/210 Posted by dan, il

(Will not be published)

  (Next time sign in to bypass captcha)

Latest in Biz

Latest on Pocket-lint.com

About Pocket-lint

Pocket-lint is your one stop shop for gadgets, technology and consumer electronics, bringing you the low-down on the latest televisions, cameras, phones, GPS and much more. Whether it's learning about what's hot in the world of Apple, finding out about the latest home cinema kit from Samsung and Sony or merely seeing what not to buy, we have you covered. So check out our reviews, news, comment, hands-on photo galleries and videos. Enjoy.

Pocket-lint.com poll

Q. Do you still buy CDs?

Vote YES Vote NO

» LAST TIME
When asked Do you want the Droid by Motorola? 53% said yes and 47% said no

Top 10 Broadband

Compare 50+
broadband packages

Home Broadband »

Top products

tip us on news

Rss feed

Follow us on Twitter