Social networking sites keep photos once they're deleted

Researchers concerned over "Zombie Photos"

Image credit: bejealousofme on Flickr
View more images

21 May 2009 15:02 GMT / By Duncan Geere

A group of security researchers at the University of Cambridge have discovered that some social networking sites keep all the photos you upload and then delete.

16 websites, including Facebook, MySpace, Bebo, Orkut, Blogger and Flickr had pictures uploaded to them. The researchers noted the URLs of the pictures, and then 'deleted' them from the site. They found that after 30 days, seven of the 16 sites were still serving the pictures.

The offenders were Bebo, Facebook, hi5, LiveJournal, MySpace, SkyRock and Xanga. Other sites took some time to take them down. Only on Flickr, Orkut, Photobucket and Windows Live Spaces did the changes have immediate effect.

The researchers say that for many sites, "photos are deleted (...) too infrequently to justify the overhead and complexity of removing them from the content delivery network". They quote Larry Lessig in saying "privacy is still considered a matter of law and not of code".

It's caused the sites in question some consternation. Xanga and Livejournal have publicly responded saying that their systems shouldn't be behaving that way, and asking the researchers to contact them with more details on how to reproduce the issues.

But for the moment, our advice would be to not upload anything that you don't think you'll want viewable in the future. It may stay online longer than you think.

Related
Full tags
Software, Websites, Online, Social networking, Privacy, Facebook, MySpace, Bebo, Orkut, Blogger, Flickr, Xanga, Photobucket, Windows, Live
UK Shopping
Amazon.co.uk, play.com, pixmania.co.uk, Currys.co.uk, Dixons.co.uk, 7dayshop.com, ebay.co.uk
US Shopping
Amazon.com, bestbuy.com, ebay.com

share Subscribe to RSS feeds email story save story print story pdf

Comments

  • duh, its obvious they keep the pictures and other content. Ever noticed the pictures in adverts where do you think they get them eps "dating adverts" Posted by anon, Demark
  • And just because the direct link to the photo has been deleted doesn't mean they don't have it. Posted by Razberi, UK
  • Are you sure you just have forgot to clear ur Cache, as i just tried to delete a few on Facebook and they went straight away after clearing browsing history. Posted by Scott, UK
  • I would expect researchers at the University of Cambridge to be doing slightly more advanced research than just uploading photos, saving the URL, deleting them and checking if the link still works....surely they should be working on making the content management system more efficient or secure if this is the reason why photos aren't deleted. Posted by al, uk
  • It is interesting to feel and see! Posted by kombizz, USA
  • i agree with al that relly took alot of work didnt come on now try a
    little harder next time     Posted by JIGSAW,

(Will not be published)

  (Next time sign in to bypass captcha)

Latest in Software

Latest on Pocket-lint.com

About Pocket-lint

Pocket-lint is your one stop shop for gadgets, technology and consumer electronics, bringing you the low-down on the latest televisions, cameras, phones, GPS and much more. Whether it's learning about what's hot in the world of Apple, finding out about the latest home cinema kit from Samsung and Sony or merely seeing what not to buy, we have you covered. So check out our reviews, news, comment, hands-on photo galleries and videos. Enjoy.

Pocket-lint.com poll

Q. Do you still buy CDs?

Vote YES Vote NO

» LAST TIME
When asked Do you want the Droid by Motorola? 53% said yes and 47% said no

Top 10 Broadband

Compare 50+
broadband packages

Home Broadband »

Top products

tip us on news

Rss feed

Follow us on Twitter