24 June 2009 9:00 GMT / By Mark Harris
According to Amazon, Kindle users buy 2.6 times as many books as other customers - and even purchase the same number of printed books that they did before. So why did one attendee of Book Expo America last month confess to wanting to punch an owner of the ebook reader?
My guess would be he’s a bookshop owner. Buying a book (or magazine or blog) on the new Amazon Kindle DX is as easy and as tempting as ploughing through a whole packet of Hob-Nobs in one sitting. The 3G wireless link is faster and more reliable than ever, presenting a great looking Kindle store with most bestsellers at half the price of traditional bookshops - all available to start reading in moments, day or night.
The larger, 9.7-screen will appeal to almost everyone, from lazy readers like myself who enjoy small fonts and a minimum of (still annoying) flickering page turns, to older readers who can finally fit more than a handful of large-print lines on one screen. The DX retains the Kindle 2’s iPod-alike smooth edges and brushed metal back, but now you’ll need two hands to manage its half-kilo weight. The smart leather cover with a magnetic latch ($50) is a must-have accessory.
Unfortunately, the DX also keeps its smaller sibling’s tiny, sharp joystick and cheap-feeling page turn buttons. The keyboard is fine for tapping in URLs on the (very, very basic) web browser but Amazon was wise to avoid any feature creep - it’s too flat and unresponsive for email, say.
The auto-rotating screen is more of an annoyance than an advance - it’s very slow to spin, books look plain weird and both websites and newspapers still display in a single column. Some PDFs (which the Kindle now reads natively) do look better in landscape mode, although you can’t zoom in, rotate or manipulate these files. At least you can turn the rotate function off.
With the extra Flash memory (now up to 3.3GB), it’s astonishing that Amazon hasn’t overhauled the Home screen, which still shows a single list of everything on the reader, sorted by date. Get more than a couple of dozen items on-board and it becomes a real mess. At least a decent search function helps you locate items, and look up words in the dictionary or online.
Away from pure reading, the text-to-speech function might be helpful for some readers (although not blind users, as it doesn’t work on the Home screen and menus), while the background MP3 player sounds better than expected, especially through headphones.
Battery life is fantastic - I’ve charged the DX once since getting it a couple of weeks ago – and the build quality feels very solid. But, unlike my old Kindle 1.0, the DX hasn’t shifted from the sofa: it’s just too large and cumbersome to find its way into my bag for day trips.
Verdict
Criticising the Kindle DX for its failings feels like dissing the electric light for not being compatible with gas fixtures. Make no mistake, this is a game-changing device that is already shaking up book, magazine and newspaper publishing. It makes buying and enjoying all kinds of written content incredibly easy, fast and straightforward.
But this is still early days for ebooks and, unless you’re a jet-setting, book-devouring traveller or someone who needs the accessibility innovations Kindle offers, the smart money is still in good, old-fashioned paper.
Unfortunately the Amazon Kindle DX is not available in the UK. In the US it is priced at $489.
Score
Review Recap
- Made by
- Amazon
- Price as reviewed
- £296
- Latest price
- Compare prices
- The good
- Looks stunning, seamless shopping, more memory, big screen
- The bad
- Sluggish interface, cheap joystick, basic formatting, awkwardly large
- Quick verdict
- Bigger? Yes. Better? Not really. More memory and better PDF handling are welcome but Kindle’s super-sized ebook reader might be too large for travellers and too small for anyone expecting a real digital newspaper
- Key specs
- 3.5mm jack, 3G
- Score
-
Recommended articles
Gadgets, ebooks, Amazon, Kindle, Amazon Kindle DX Ebook, eBook readers, Amazon Kindle













APP OF THE DAY: Tom Daley Dive 2012 review (iPad / iPhone / iPod touch) Splooosh!
Sony Vaio E Series pictures and hands-on Everyday laptops
Motorola RAZR MAXX pictures and hands-on "Longest talktime of any smartphone"
Canon EOS 650D coming in June - specs leaked About time and all
Lego creates exclusive Team GB Olympic minifigs Going for gold
Diablo III collector's edition pictures and hands-on
Sony Vaio T13 Ultrabook pictures and hands-on Sony's first Ultra
Sony Vaio S Series pictures and hands-on 13-incher fondled
Want to transfer Android apps to a Windows Phone? Microsoft would like to help Showing App-titude
Samsung Galaxy S III receives 9 million pre-orders Are you one of the crowd?
ICANN and the dot anything: do we care about domain names? The web is changing
Olympic diving hope Tom Daley gets own iOS game Tom Daley Dive 2012
WIN: Tickets to Ibiza Rocks to see Maverick Sabre and Labrinth live Epic prize courtesy of Sony
Cisco Linksys X3000 One for basic users
Steve Jobs dreamt of creating an iCar What might have been
Olympus OM-D E-M5 review
The compact system camera to beat all others?
Nokia Lumia 900 review
Is big beautiful?
HTC One V review
V for victory?
Huawei Ascend G300 review
Big bang for your hundred quid
FIFA 12: UEFA Euro 2012 review
Lacks polish, if not the Polish
Asus Transformer Pad TF300T review
Transforms your money in to a great tablet
BlackBerry Mini Keyboard for PlayBook review
Will this make working on the go easier?
Fujifilm X-Pro1 review
Like a Leica
Nikon Coolpix P510 review
Does the P510 zoom beyond expectations?
Volkswagen Beetle Design 1.2TSi DSG review
The bug is back. Again.
The Walking Dead: The Game review
Fleshed out zombie bonanza
HP Envy 14 Spectre review
The Ultrabook that isn't an Ultrabook
Nikon Coolpix S6300 review
Point, shoot and scoot
Fujifilm FinePix HS30EXR review
Can Fujifilm’s latest put the ‘super’ in superzoom?